[Before we begin, let me make it perfectly clear that I have no intention of disappearing!]
This very short book isn't exactly bursting at the seams with deep expertise, but it does offer certain insights and it's an amusing read. The author does not know quite enough about his subject to tell readers everything they need to know to disappear, and so it leaves the book a bit of a disappointment--albeit an entertaining one.
Somehow, this author managed to connect up with a wide range of different individuals, all men[1], who successfully staged their own disappearances. What he shares here, therefore, is entirely vicarious--although he learned enough that the so-called "experts" working at various missing persons bureaus were asking him about the various techniques involved.
You'll also find some of the subsidiary themes of this 1980s-era book (like how to obtain a new identity, how to move about untraced, among others) have become obsolete in the modern surveillance state. At the same time, however, a surprising amount of the advice here is far more timeless than you'd expect.
One final thought: it's always fascinating to read about people doing things you would never do. Maybe that's why we read: books give us a window into these experiences... without any of the consequences.
Footnote:
[1] Not all disappearees are men, but men were the only disappearees who talked to him. As the author puts it, a woman who disappears--likely for her own safety--would be highly unlikely to talk about it to someone she didn't know intimately.
[A quick affiliate link to Amazon for those readers who would like to support my work here: if you purchase your Amazon products via any affiliate link from this site, or from my sister site Casual Kitchen, I will receive a small affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you!]
[Feel free to skip the rest of this post: what follows are just my notes and reactions to the book.]
Notes:
Introduction:
1ff On the author randomly encountering someone on a bus in Mexico who enchanted him with a disappearance story "of his friend"; on the author's process of finding and meeting different people who had done the same; also it's a bit of hilarious to read here that the people working in "missing persons" at the police department knew so little about the subject of disappearing, that they began asking the author about the techniques involved.
3 "I have talked with hundreds of people about the art of disappearing and switching identities. What follows is a collection of anecdotes from the lives of the disappeared showing what motivated them to leave, how they created their new identities and the way they live the new lives they have built."
Who disappears--And Why
4ff On how statistics on missing persons are totally unreliable: most "disappearees" are never reported; a small number of people are missing who are actually not; fugitives are not going to be "reported missing"; also various reasons why a husband or wife might not want to report their spouse leaving them; comments on teenage runaways who are outside the scope of this book. [Note here that the author makes an intriguing comment here that one of the interesting aspects of teenage runaways is how is that they often possess the skills and background to become successful adult runaways, as they have severed their emotional family ties early in life while developing the skills to survive as 'strangers in strange lands.'"]
8ff On why people disappear: the author names three major motivations: legal, financial and psychological--or a combination of the three. "The successful disappearee usually has a taste for risk, the ability to think and act quickly, and either a strong resistance to, or fear of, re-connecting with their past."
9ff Specific reasons that compel people to abandon their former lives, including marriage, divorce and revenge; the author shares an extended anecdote about a man who walked out on his wife after she initiated highly extractive divorce proceedings on him.
12ff Per the author, it is rare for a woman to leave and disappear on her husband: usually it's due to abuse and violence. The author also admits openly here that he has not ever talked with a woman disappearee. "...a woman who has disappeared out of fear for her safety is not likely to reveal her secret to anyone she hasn't come to know intimately."
13ff Interesting [and quite frankly disturbing] comments here about revenge disappearances that may put the wife in a very difficult position. "The abandoned wife is, in almost all respects, in a far worse position than a widow. All her alternatives will be expensive and difficult, including hiring detectives to find him, getting a divorce or having him declared legally dead. And she is not likely to have many resources at her disposal to pay for these things." On the fact that it'll be a year or longer before she can sell any joint property in his or their names; likewise in the meantime she'll still be liable for making payments for any joint property, like mortgage or car payments.
14 While one might think that disappearances would be more common with people who have two wives or families; in reality, the author makes a good point here: "Contrary to widely-held opinion, the 'the other woman' is seldom a serious factor in most decisions to effect a deliberate disappearance, and it is rare for a man to disappear and take his 'sidelines lover' with him. This is probably due to the practical reason that engineering the disappearance of two people is vastly more complicated than one."
15 On the "Gauguin Syndrome," named after the French stockbroker who chucked everything to paint and ultimately contracted syphilis in the South Sea Islands. Comments here on men who hit their middle years and realize they're never going to make it big, they'll never become CEO, they'll never be rich like they dreamed; some of them commit suicide, while most just just make it through by, as the author puts it "gritting their teeth and continuing right on schlepping." The author shares an anecdote about a man whose wife divorced him, getting the house, the car and custody of the kids; while the husband, a low-paid teacher, still had to pay both alimony and child support. The man engineered a disappearance in response and began an entirely new life.
20 Anecdotes on amnesia: the author argues that this is very rare, that it's more common than a disappearee would plead "amnesia" when he returned--and the family would accept this flimsy explanation because it's less embarrassing to all concerned. Finally comments here on people with deep contempt for "the system" with its various petty regulations that businesses and governments use to control the masses. [These last comments would resonate with the authors of Perpetual Traveler and How I Found Freedom in an Unfree World.]
How--The Mechanics of Disappearing
22ff The author tells a story about a man who planned a disappearance but didn't realize it at the time. The author calls it "an unpremeditated disappearance." The author met him while riding a bus from Nogales, Arizona to Mazatlan in Mexico. The author noticed that the man, Capa, spoke fluent Spanish but spoke it with a Southern US accent. Capa replied, "I'll have to watch out for that in the future." He was from upper-class Southern family, he married "properly" but he and his wife didn't love or even like each other. He had a dream of boating, learned all he could about it, and had a spontaneous, unexpected opportunity to be a first mate on a sailboat heading to Panama, in the long run adopting a new identity in El Salvador. After about a year the wife had him declared legally dead, collected on his life insurance and then remarried.
31ff The author breaks down this guy's story, first he had luckily stumbled into a new identity, he'd already been studying boating and sailing; the main thing he did is actually take action, leaving his old life behind.
32 Note the author's intriguing discussion here of "pseudocide" [giving the impression that you are dead] and how it compares with actual suicide in the sense that once you decide to do it your mood lifts and a great weight is lifted from your shoulders. Also to others around you, it seems all the more surprising as they likewise see your mood lift: "I can't understand why John would want to kill himself. We might have understood it better a few months ago when he was so upset about his life, but he had been so happy late. It doesn't make sense." [Heavy]
32-3 "Disappearing is a form of suicide. It is a revocable kind of death where one destroys his old life but not his chance to start a new one. If the new life doesn't work out as planned he can step back into his old one, though it probably won't be the same. If he's gone very long, he may never be able to regain his family or his job. That's why most disappearees who are gone more than a few weeks never return unless they're fugitives who are hunted down and brought back by the law."
33ff More discussion here of pseudocide: on a doctor who investigated 100 cases of apparent suicide at the Golden Gate Bridge where no body was recovered; of the 100 he (easily) found 26 who were alive and well. The author also writes here that the very first suicide from the San Francisco Bay Bridge was a pseudocide: it was a councilman caught up in a dispute over embezzlement, and he was later found selling Bibles door-to0door in Texas.
35ff On the importance of doing this alone: if you have an accomplice or a family member involved they won't be able to withstand pressures exerted on them by relatives or the police. "Your friend may help you destroy your old life but doesn't want to see your scheme destroy his life."
36 "It is very difficult for a person to successfully change identities alone. It is damn near impossible to do it in tandem."
37 On obtaining identification for your new identity: the author cites the fixation on paperwork in the modern world. "It isn't who you are that counts, but whether you can prove it!" The author tells the reader there's a whole chapter of this book devoted to establish an ID: he recommends you consider it before making a break for it because it can take months to put together a complete set of identification even under ideal circumstances. He first recommends getting a confidential mailing address, and also to send some assets from your former life ahead of you into that new life. Many mail drop services offer an address along with the ability to send, receive, open or destroy or forward mail; the author also suggests renting desk space or workspace from a company that offers services to salesmen or small businesses, and you can use that as your business or residence address; you can also hire them to handle phone calls and mail; this could then be used to fabricate references for an employment application.
39ff On the terrible risks of taking your car with you when you disappear: it makes you very easy to find. The author tells a totally unrelated but kind of funny story here about a man who took a car he and his wife were fighting over to a wrecking yard; he donated the parts of the car to the yard in return for them not looking too closely at the legal paperwork and then had them fold the car's carcass up into a cube out of spite.
40 Comments here on not immediately leaving the country unless you have a full set of US ID papers.
40ff Discussion here of "official" requirements of Mexico to enter the country: you technically need a passport but the author argues here that you can enter as a tourist without documentation, even by paying a small fee or a propina. [In the mid-2010s I drove into Sonora state via the Mariposa Nogales border crossing (just to the west of the main Nogales crossing), and I never interacted with anyone at the Mexican border. [!] There was just a bank of cameras that I don't think were even working. I was shocked.]
42-3 The author also talks about how Mexico is someone xenophobic and it's difficult to get work there. It's interesting to read the author's cautions here about Mexico. "Living in Mexico is the answer for only a very, very small minority of Yankee disappearees."
43 Comments on reading Ronald George Erickson's book How to Find Missing Persons "backwards": in other words read it to understand how people will go about looking for you; on thinking about who might look for you and what means they might use to try to find you. Cynical comments here about the "missing persons bureau" which the author considers an afterthought, "mostly designed to keep anxious relatives out of the desk sergeant's hair and track down runaway juveniles." The cops won't likely put crack detectives on this beat, and they won't mount an expensive, usually fruitless search; thus a person making a planned deliberate disappearance "has little to fear in the way of apprehension by the local police department's Missing Persons Bureau."
44ff Extended tangent here on Larry Lavin, a man who assumed a new identity and managed to escape the FBI for some number of years, until ultimately being found a few years later; the author's point here [I think?] is to take the feds much more seriously than a local police missing persons bureau.
48 Comments here on private eyes that wealthy families may hire to find you; also skip tracers who are used to find missing heirs, stockholders or alumni; even comments on The Salvation Army which will also search for people using their international reach, although they will only act on behalf of a missing person's immediate family or in instances where it's to the person's benefit to be located. Also final comments on how an insurance company may mount a more intensive search over a very large insurance payout.
Creating a Bullet-Proof Identity
51ff The insights from this chapter largely come from one of the author's interviewees. On how a genuine identity used by an imposter is superior to a manufactured identity because the latter won't withstand the same level of scrutiny; the idea here is you want to "locate" an identity rather than fabricate one.
52ff Comments here on risks of assuming the identity of another living person: that person will have a very strong interest in putting a halt to someone else's use of their identification; also if the State Department discovers two people have passports with the same names and vital statistics this is going to be an enormous problem if you try to enter the US or renew your passport. Thus you do have to assume the identity of another living person make sure it's "someone who is totally undistinguished and unremarkable."
55ff On using the identity of someone who's dead. "One of the beautiful things about the United States is that there's very little correlation between birth and death records. The official papers on births and deaths are kept in the smallest political subdivisions, such as towns, cities and counties. There is no central federal agency that keeps tabs on all this information. And the rules and regulations on recording births and deaths differ from state to state." Ideas here including using a war buddy; a childhood friend who passed away; even using headstones for information and a starting place for research; using as newspaper obituaries in small towns; records of accidents or disasters (ideally those that happen outside the US) where you can find a list of victims; on using personnel records from a company where you can find dossiers of deceased employees.
57ff On considering secondary characteristics as you seek out an identity that suits your purposes: you'll want a name that doesn't cry out for attention; the author recommends avoiding Spanish-sounding surnames due to potential immigration difficulties. [given the author originally wrote this book in 1986, and given the massive demographic changes in the USA since then, you might actually want to do the opposite today.] On seeking an identity of someone with a college degree, since this may help you get a job; one the idea that you might otherwise need to go back to school, and the fact that even this could be good under your a new identity because you come under less scrutiny as a student, as employers or neighbors won't ask as many questions about your past if you've only recently graduated from college. On avoiding the identity of someone with specialized skills you don't have. On avoiding assuming the identity of someone who left a family behind because they may be collecting benefits as a result of the death, thus if you appropriate such an identity you may trigger a connection if someone's monthly check disappears because of you.
59ff Next you build a new identity by assuming the identity of someone who has died without having their death officially noted in the place they were born. Also on hiring a law school student or a moonlighting legal researcher to do the background research for you. Comments here on not worrying about arousing suspicion by requesting a copy of a birth certificate: lots of people lose them; also the author tells the reader to pay all fees using money orders and do all correspondence through a mail drop, thus making it harder to trace you. Also note the example given here of a person using a lawyer to get a birth certificate by saying he was looking for a missing heir and needed to see the potential heir's birth certificate; the attorney was easily able to get a certified copy.
61 "Once you have the birth certificate, getting the rest of the documents you need is a piece of cake. [It's hard to believe this stuff could work today in a much more heavily networked world, but who knows.] We'll take a look at a few of the more important pieces of ID you will want to acquire." Discussion of your social security number, "one of the trickier pieces of ID to get." Don't use the number that came with your new identity because you'll trigger bells and whistles at the Social Security Administration; likewise don't use your old number for the same reason. The author suggest using the ruse of saying you've been a student, that you've been living abroad, or that your parents moved to Canada when you were young, etc. [This seems a stretch, but I don't know enough to know.]
62ff You can also use your birth certificate and run down to the DMV to get a driver's license. "The respect given to a drivers license as positive identification is astonishing, even comforting, though by no means is it justified by the evidence."
64ff Finally on getting a passport once you have the proper backup ID; Comments here also on why you should never try to obtain having forged identification: you're at the mercy of those who forged them for you, it's exhorbitantly expensive; the documents may be stolen, etc.
Coping
69 The author argues here that documenting a new identity is "not all that difficult" but the hardest aspect of disappearing is coping with the change in lifestyle as you establish yourself as a new person. The author refers back to the well-planned disappearance of Larry Lavin, whose entire plan was tripped up by a couple of seemingly minor oversights.
70ff The author shares a story of a man telling him about a "friend" who bought it pickup truck camper under his new identity; on how little it costs a man to live in a camper by himself, on how he started a second career with some carpentry skills that he had learned over the years, so he did odd jobs at first, then gradually developed steadier and steadier work as a carpenter. The takeaway here [I guess?] is to note how he had prepared all of his transportation in advance and has set aside money to buy his vehicle beforehand.
74 The funny comment here about having your car "stolen" by leaving it unlocked in a poor neighborhood with the keys in it.
74ff Comments on bus travel as the best form of transportation because they don't keep passenger lists and don't require you to show ID to get a ticket [This is almost certainly not true nowadays]. Also similarly obsolete comments here about airline travel in the post 9/11 world. On how using rental cars is not a good idea because you need to use a credit card, "and if there's one thing a recent disappearee lacks, it's credit."
75ff On your first days on your own the author recommends absolutely not staying with friends or relatives because once again it puts them under pressure; however, the author also says it's not a good idea to live on the street because this crowd is carefully watched by the police and thus you might be found; he argues it's better to stay in a mission like the Salvation Army, which has experience assisting many people and is not likely to make embarrassing inquiries.
78 On the risk of staying in small town USA where there might be significant interest in a new outsider, with speculation about your background. The author argues that it is much better to stay in a big city with more anonymity, millions of people, extensive mass transit, more job opportunities, and more services that a disappearee will need, like maildrops, secretarial services etc.
78ff Note the intriguing comment on how certain disappearees would design a second exit into any place they lived. [I think one could also interpret this metaphorically and think about an exit from whatever new life you arrange for yourself.]
79ff Comments here on the importance of working, or at least having the appearance of working, to structure your life so that it attracts as little attention to yourself as possible. On working as a means to establish credit for your new identity; how work helps assuage loneliness which is a severe problem for many identity-changers; general thoughts here on white collar workers who move to blue collar work or blue collar workers who change trades; also comments on construction work which during booms there's going to be so much demand for manpower you can get work even if you don't have developed skills. Also on temporary agency work: temp agencies ask fewer questions about your background, and temp work can lead to a full-time position with a company you work for; also comments here on avoiding any kind of work that puts you in the public eye: the author cites wide-ranging here, anything from media work to even being a bellhop.
83ff On using your mail drops to create fictitious companies that you've "worked for," with letterhead, letters of reference, responses to your employer's requests for information, etc. The author recommends avoiding any mention of special honors or anything unusual with your new identity, since it makes it easier to find an inconsistency in your background; in fact the author says don't even talk or mention or say anything about any kind of educational degree; better to buy new ones by mail order, or use the specific education you build with your new shell identity by going through the educational process for a new set of degrees.
86ff Comments on how to get credit; cute here how the author suggest to go to like a layaway store and get a history of making payments, then attempt to get a department store credit card or two, and then work up to getting a major credit card; also on the risk that you might have assumed the identity of someone who had debt or bad credit record: this is why you only want to assume so much of another's identity, not necessarily his social security number: you will want a new, pristine social security number instead.
89ff Comments here on disguise: the author talks about how you will at some point run into someone you haven't seen in years, and all it takes is one of them to connect you to your past "and you're a goner." Thus "a wee bit of disguise" is a good idea. Discussion here of how it can be as simple as changing your haircut. Discussion here of six general ways someone is recognized: gait, overall appearance, shape of the head and face, voice, physical features and location. On how it's easy to default back to your original gait, thus you should wear different shoes; interesting here to read the author's suggestion to add a quarter inch to one shoe and subtract a quarter inch from the heel of the other shoe: this will automatically force you to adjust your gait. See another idea: put a small particle of something into your shoe which will automatically change your walking style.
91ff Comments on clothing, posture and weight: the author refers to how when we see someone out of context--like we see our dentist out in the real world--we often completely fail to recognize them; also someone who normally wears suits would be unnoticed in laborers' clothing; you definitely want to blend into the background and not wear anything that gets attention; also the author suggests wearing glasses or sunglasses, especially if you never wore glasses before; other ideas here like wearing a lot more jewelry (or hardly any, whatever would be different from the "previous you"), growing or shaving facial hair, changing your teeth, even gaining or losing a significant amount of weight--which will change your facial features as well.
93ff On changing your language, or your accent: per the author these things are very difficult to do; "it is a lot easier to fall into the vocabulary of your class than it is to change and accent or dialect."
95ff More comments here on not leaving a paper trail, avoiding government buildings as much as possible, staying away from public activities like protests, avoiding membership in publicity-seeking clubs or groups; on avoiding being photographed and watching out for cameras around you.
98 Comments here about never going around with more than one set of ID papers on your person, never carry contraband, etc.
99ff Comments here on permanently detaching with your past: an interesting anecdote here of one disappearee who was an avid model boat builder, and once he established his new identity he resubscribed to the hobby publications he read before he vanished. Ultimately he was found by private detectives who assumed he would resume his lifelong hobby: they bought the mailing list of these magazines, checking them for new subscribers. Also you do not want a money trail between your identities, you should only use cash; never make a phone call to your old numbers; mailing should be done using a remailing service; ideally there should be no communicating at all with your prior life, even to keep track of the activities of your abandoned family; also an amusing warning here do not ever tell young (or not-so-young) ladies about your identity change: "identity changers of all people should know only too well how vindictive a woman can be when sufficiently provoked."
Postscript
103 Here the author celebrates disappearees for taking action to deal with a life they didn't like, instead of just bitching about it. "...they are the only group that has come anywhere near to beating the system. I salute them!"
To Read:
Ronald George Erickson: How to Find Missing Persons: A Handbook for Investigators ["definitive" and to be read "backwards" to think through how others will search for you]
Michael Collins: The Brass Rainbow
Jane Askin: Search
Jay Robert Nash: Among the Missing
Bill Conners: How to Steal a Job
Adam Cash: Guerilla Capitalism: How to Practice Free Enterprise in an Unfree Economy ["definitive"]
Adam Cash: How to do Business "Off the Books"
Bill Pryor: Personal and Business Privacy
Bill Kaysing: Privacy: How to Get It, How to Enjoy It ["excellent"]
John Sample: Methods of Disguise
William Petrocelli: Low Profile
Michael Conner: How to Hide Anything
