Skip to main content

Live and Let Die by Ian Fleming [review short]

These are fun throwaway novels. Occasionally a really well-turned phrase, interesting settings, good plots and memorable villains. The book Live and Let Die is so much better than the movie featuring Roger Moore that I almost feel pity for my generation who grew up thinking that was James Bond.

The allegedly racist parts of the novel (the parts that are shortly to be sanitized) aren't particularly racist, with the unfortunate exception of Chapter 5 (lamentably titled "Nigger Heaven"). This chapter is actually rather tone deaf: Fleming did not appear to know Harlem all that well, he attempts to write in a sort of dialect... He tried. It's presumably with the aim of creating what would feel like a thrilling, exotic atmosphere to his 1950s-era readers in England, but it's beyond his ability as a writer to do it convincingly. 

Notes:
* "I smoke about three packs a day." The James Bond of the novels remains far more interesting than the modern smoke-free and vice-free Bond of the movies. The modern movie Bond obviously can't smoke; he can't even womanize. 

* Funny subtle reference here to the OG of the USA's Deep State, J. Edgar Hoover: "Bond laughed. 'What an organization!' [the FBI] he said. 'I'm sure it's all beautifully covered up and alibied. What a man! He [Hoover] certainly seems to have the run of this country. Just shows how one can push a democracy around, what with habeas corpus and human rights and all the rest. Glad we haven't got him on our hands in England." 

* Note Bond and Leiter's abject horror at all the old people in southern Florida. Quite a contrast with today's forever young Boomers teeming all over places like The Villages.

* Also an offhand reference to NJ before it became overrun:


* Interesting (pseudo-?) history about the pirate Captain "Bloody" Morgan, who practiced his piracy on Spanish shipping in the 1600s, and whose activity England indirectly supported, but later disavowed in order to avoid a war with Spain. It does make you think about different types of non-governmental "hard" and "soft power": where countries will use indirect instruments of power to project force, destabilize shipping lanes, etc. It's interesting to think about how piracy would actually be supported by a government if it helped that government's interests. Makes you think.

* "This was Quarrel, the Cayman Islander, and Bond liked him immediately. There was the blood of Cromwellian soldiers and buccaneers in him and his face was strong and angular and his mouth was almost severe. His eyes were grey. It was only the spatulate nose and the pale palms of his hands that were negroid." It's always striking to read how much English writers (and presumably English culture) used and depended on physiognomy to describe and predict behavior. You see it from Shakespeare to Austin, to Dickens and right up until the mid 20th century... where all notions of physiognomy suddenly disappear from the record. 

* The climax happens in the last ten pages and it requires an unbelievably lucky coincidence of timing.

To Read:
Wilfred Trotter: Instincts of the Herd in War and Peace

More Posts

Why We Sleep by Matthew Walker

Tedious, weak, and worst of all  "riddled" with errors  and oversights. Do not read. I recommend instead  Dreaming: A Very Short Introduction  by J. Allan Hobson  for information about the REM/dreaming stage of sleep, as well as  Restful Sleep  by Deepak Chopra  for readers interested in practical help for improving sleep quality. Unlike Why We Sleep , both of these books are short, direct, readable and clear. Sadly, I also have to spend a brief few sentences  on Alexey Guzey's devastating criticisms of this book . Alexey's entire post is very much worth reading, but if you want to see just one glaring example of atrocious academic ethics, you can start with a chart Matthew Walker uses in Chapter 6 to prove a linear relationship between sleep loss and sports injury-- except that he cuts off the part of the chart that disproves his argument . This is childish middle school stuff, way beneath the line of a Berkeley and Harvard professor, a...

By All Means Available: Memoirs of a Life in Intelligence, Special Operations, and Strategy by Michael G. Vickers

The least deceptive way to read this endless, muddled and minutia-laden memoir would be to view it as a very long piece of propaganda: a type of limited hangout of all of the covert (and overt) things the United States does globally in its attempts to project power. It can also be read as an attempt at an extended--and I mean extended --defense of the CIA and all of its meddlings all over the world. This is if you actually read the book. Don't. Piled up with words but saying little of substance, this is the most obfuscatory memoir I've ever read. The author's voice fundamentally irritates: he has a compulsive need to share staggering amounts of unnecessary detail, he comes across as a relentless credit hog, and he repeatedly attempts to place himself right in the middle of the action--even when it's clear he wasn't. Perhaps least ethical of all, he has a habit of framing his actions and decisions so they appear more correct and predictive in retrospect than they ac...

The Dhandho Investor by Mohnish Pabrai

Worth reading, and rereading, and re-rereading. An elegant book that teaches fundamental principles of value investing, and much more. The Dhandho Investor  also has the highly unusual quality of being useful at a wide range of reader sophistication levels: you can gain tremendously from this book as a beginner or as a deeply experienced investor. I'll single out Chapters 5 and 6 for particular mention: Chapter 5 describes author Mohnish Pabrai's investing framework, with nine interlocking and synchronistic rules. Chapter 6 describes in very simple language all of the gigantic structural advantages of investing in the stock market, as it offers low frictional costs, a tremendous selection of possible businesses, and, most importantly, periodic incredible opportunities. These two chapters explain why you will take a pass on almost all investments--but then, once in a while, make large bets on specific situations that meet your requirements. [A quick  affiliate link to Amazon ...