Skip to main content

The Checklist Manifesto by Atul Gawande

By describing how good hospitals and surgical centers could be, Atul Gawande indirectly--and likely without intending to do so--describes quite a number of ugly truths about how they actually are.

The truth is, more likely than not, the surgery team cutting you open isn't a coherent team. They likely don't even know each others' names. Surgeons as a rule generally resist using basic checklist procedures to prevent infection risk and catastrophic errors. In fact, Gawande finds surgeons often offended by the very idea! 

Worst of all, the hospitals they work for likely don't even know--and don't want to know--their error rates, complication rates, infection rates and death rates. After all, what's the incentive to track data that might make you look bad? 

 The idea that it could be as difficult as Gawande finds it to get surgery teams to use basic checklists (something the airline industry has done for generations to produce astoundingly good safety records) is staggering. But it illustrates an excellent example of a "skin in the game" problem, and it explains why pilots are happy to use checklists if they improve safety, while surgeons ego-resist the idea. 

 Why? Because the pilot is actually on the plane with you. The moment the surgeon closes you up and ships you off, you become somebody else's problem. On to the next patient. 

Finally, this reader received from this highly useful book one more valuable--and almost certainly unintended--message: Do not have surgery unless absolutely necessary.

More Posts

Perpetuity by Kevin Joseph [new fiction release]

A fast-moving, speculative sci-fi thriller, and a fun read!  After helping a fellow runner who cut her foot on a nail, a young doctor inadvertently discovers a dangerous secret in her blood, a secret that puts them in direct conflict with shadowy forces in the biotech industry. Suddenly, they find themselves running for their lives, threatened by the US government... and even more powerful enemies. Perpetuity uses several character perspectives, and the reader gradually pieces together the book's reality through various characters' eyes. I appreciate any novel that is well-structured to the point that the reader doesn't actually "see" the structure, but can just enjoy the story as it unfolds. It's harder to do than it looks. The author has a tight, noirish writing style and a knack for capturing archetypal characters. Two examples: you'll meet a smarmy, arriviste tech CEO rendered perfectly, right down to the condescending internal monologue running in hi...

The Wars of America (Vol 1) by Robert Leckie

This is a massive and capably-written history, the first of two volumes. It will fill in a lot of the cracks in any reader's historical knowledge of the USA--especially if you're like me, someone whose historical knowledge has more cracks than foundation. Recommended as either a starting point to learn about each conflict, or as a finishing point to groove and firm up what you already know. Before I get to the book itself, let me share a brief thought on the absolute necessity of reading history--but specifically, reading history from historians who lived outside your own time period.  Current history writing is subject to a variety of problems, starting with the historians themselves, who are necessarily products of the time in which they live. They hold their era's consensus narratives, and they'll have no choice but to filter their views through modernity. The modern publishing industry adds yet another layer of problems: it acts as a gatekeeping institution, both di...

The Practicing Mind by Thomas M. Sterner

This short and humble book will be priceless to an open-minded reader.  It discusses how to cultivate present-moment awareness, how to focus on process rather than product, how to make haste slowly, and many other practices that are increasingly indispensable in our haste-filled, results-oriented modern era. Several years ago I heard an unforgettable story from the owner of a language school in Santiago, Chile. She told me about a disgruntled customer who had been taking Spanish classes for weeks, but wasn't getting any better. This student complained, loudly, "I paid my money. Where is my Spanish?" This story stuck with me for well over a decade because it's a metaphor for how people confuse buying something with learning something, confuse "taking a class" with actually learning a domain and developing a sincere practice of that domain. We've productized so much of life in the modern era that people think they can buy language fluency off the shelf, li...