Skip to main content

Death at La Fenice by Donna Leon [Commissario Brunetti #1] [review short: no spoilers]

A famous opera conductor with an awful secret is murdered, poisoned with cyanide, during intermission at the Venice opera. This is the first of the "Commissario Brunetti" series, and it's quite a competent mystery. The author has a knack for revealing aspects of her characters gradually and naturally over the course of the narrative, and readers get a fun mini-course in Italian cultural nuances as they read.

It's good enough that you'll want to read the next.

Finally, I'll mention one beautiful and mournful scene from this novel that stands out: Chapter 14, where Inspector Brunetti visits a dark, forgotten part of Venice to interview a very old, once-famous opera singer in her home. You can feel the loneliness right through the pages, it's so well done.

Notes:
* On what it's like living in a city like Venice that's slowly but surely evolving into a sort of outdoor museum for tourists and becoming less and less a place for actual Italians to live. 

* "Brunetti closed his notebook, in which he had done no more than scribble the American's last name, as if to capture the full horror of a word composed of five consonants."

* Brunetti's wife Paola always chooses a suspect at the beginning of any of his investigations; Brunetti considers it both charming and naive as his wife tends to pick the "too obvious" suspect, which is almost always the wrong suspect. Almost always.

* "Not for the first time in his career, Brunetti reflected upon the possible advantage of censorship of the press. In the past, the German people had got along very well with a government that demanded it, and the American government seemed to fare similarly well with a population that wanted it."

* On the thin layer of corruption underlying everything: characters will comment on things like how the corruption in Venice, such as it is, is still way less than in Sicily; or see for example another scene where Inspector Brunetti, out of sheer curiosity, directly asks a character how in the world she was able to get a permit to install skylights in her top floor apartment: she answers, bluntly, "I bribed the inspector," and then tells him the precise amount!

More Posts

Good Thinking: The Foundations of Probability and its Applications by Irving J. Good

This collection of scientific papers is a challenging but useful discussion on statistical methods, probability, randomness, logic and decision-making. Much of the book centers around Bayesian statistical methods and when and why to use them, as well as "philosophy of science"-type discussions on when a scientist should--or sometimes must--apply subjective judgments to scientific problems. It will help enormously if you've had a semester or two of statistics to really get at the meat of this book. If not, scroll down a few paragraphs for a short list of layperson-friendly books that address many of these subjects more accessibly. [A quick  affiliate link to Amazon  for those readers who would like to support my work here: if you purchase your Amazon products via any affiliate link from this site, or from my sister site  Casual Kitchen , I will receive a small affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you!] Author Irving Good worked with Alan Turing at ...

Why We Sleep by Matthew Walker

Tedious, weak, and worst of all  "riddled" with errors  and oversights. Do not read. I recommend instead  Dreaming: A Very Short Introduction  by J. Allan Hobson  for information about the REM/dreaming stage of sleep, as well as  Restful Sleep  by Deepak Chopra  for readers interested in practical help for improving sleep quality. Unlike Why We Sleep , both of these books are short, direct, readable and clear. Sadly, I also have to spend a brief few sentences  on Alexey Guzey's devastating criticisms of this book . Alexey's entire post is very much worth reading, but if you want to see just one glaring example of atrocious academic ethics, you can start with a chart Matthew Walker uses in Chapter 6 to prove a linear relationship between sleep loss and sports injury-- except that he cuts off the part of the chart that disproves his argument . This is childish middle school stuff, way beneath the line of a Berkeley and Harvard professor, a...

Ghost Boy by Martin Pistorius

Read this book and you'll never complain, ever, about anything. Imagine being trapped in a vegetative body but with full cognition and awareness. You can hear, see and understand everything, but you can't move or do anything. Everyone around you--your family, your caregivers, everyone--thinks you're a literal vegetable. And some of those around you will act like it, having insulting conversations about you while you're right there. Some caregivers--not all of them, mercifully--will handle you like a slab of meat. Occasionally you'll be rolled over to a performative "activity" in which a caregiver drags your fingerpainted hand across a paper, so your care facility can show your family you aren't spending all day staring at the wall. But yet you do spend most of your time staring at the wall, or worse, watching Barney . You will come to hate Barney with all your soul. Imagine living like this. For years . Until one caregiver really looks at you, really...