Skip to main content

Medical Nemesis: The Expropriation of Health by Ivan Illich

This book was profoundly useful, giving the reader a set of extraordinarily helpful lenses to better understand both the modern medical/healthcare industry, but also to better understand modernity itself. Although this book is primarily about healthcare, it is also prescient in identifying many of the alienating and atomizing aspects of modern civilization. This book may have been written in the early 1970s, but the author was decades ahead of his time.

One of the foundational concepts of this book is iatrogenesis, which essentially means “harm done by the healer.” I was first exposed to this word thanks to Nassim Taleb in his book Antifragile. In Medical Nemesis, Ivan Illich begins with a discussion of medical iatrogenics in the most basic sense, but then expands the concept into far broader terms, discussing three genres of iatrogenesis: 1) clinical iatrogenesis, 2) social iatrogenesis, and 3) cultural iatrogenesis: 

1) Clinical iatrogenesis is the “plain vanilla form” of iatrogenesis: damage done to a patient by a doctor. It can be caused by doctor incompetence, by accident, by a doctor to protect his own legal liability (by ordering tests or procedures that may or may not be necessary to the patient but serve to cover the doctor's legal risk), or by unknown reasons. 

2) Social iatrogenesis is a form of damage done when the medical practice or our government encourages or reinforces society to become greater and greater over-consumers of healthcare. This can come from overscreening, overmedicating, from disease-mongering or from labeling people as sick who may not actually be. This includes “breeding” new categories of patients, who can then be encouraged to pay for meds or treatment to “fix” them. Also, we are subject to various grooming practices, even from childhood, to encourage us to tolerate various behaviors: doctors who “use a foreign language” (medical terminology) while they discuss our case right in front of us; doctors who may perform tests or perform actions (even pain-inducing actions) without explanation or apology, etc.

3) Cultural iatrogenesis is when the healthcare industry interferes with people's potential to deal on their own with human weakness and vulnerability. Examples might be: interfering in healthy responses to suffering and impairment. Or, undermining the individual’s ability to face their reality and accept inevitable decline and death. Think of it like a second-order iatrogenesis that sickens and weakens us culturally. 

The modern phrase “evidence-based healthcare”--widely used by healthcare evangelists and propagandists--should trigger alarm bells in the mind of any critical thinker. Once anyone has even the most basic familiarly with the great crisis of reproducibility, to say nothing of the various other problems suffusing all “studies show” science findings (p-hacking, file drawer effects, statistical gerrymandering, overdependence on Gaussian/normal curve statistical analysis, etc.), one cannot hear the words “evidence-based healthcare” without a sense of bitter irony. 

In the modern era we are trained to use money as a solution for everything, including our health. Thus we pay for meds, doctor’s appointments, surgeries, insurance... while we demand more and more government support and funding for “healthcare.” All of this, circularly, simply contributes to the desire to buy our way out of all situations, including buying our way out of reality--and even out of death itself. And of course along the way we have become an enormously overmedicated society. 

I also wonder what this author would think--as he laments the upward explosion of healthcare spending from 4% of GDP in the 1960s to 8% in the 1970s--to know that today healthcare costs exceed 20% of GDP (!) as life expectancy and life quality are actually declining.

It is slowly becoming clear to me that iatrogenesis is a feature, not a bug, of modern healthcare--and possibly of modern society in general. It is endemic in many more ways than we realize. And once you can “see” iatrogenics, you can never unsee it.

Update: there is a free online PDF version of this book here. Save yourself a copy. Given the samizdat nature of this book, Medical Nemesis may become increasingly difficult to find in the coming years.

More Posts

For Good and Evil: The Impact of Taxes on the Course of Civilization by Charles Adams

Wide-ranging historical survey looking at major world civilizations through the lens of taxation and tax policy. It's a good read, a great review of world history, and it gets you to think about that history in a refreshingly unusual way. I've said elsewhere that one cannot understand history properly without some grounding in monetary history . Add tax history to the list! The author makes a robust argument that many if not most political instabilities and revolutions largely emerge out of resistance to punitive taxation. Likewise, this book will help deprogram readers away from the many schoolbook historical narratives we carry around, like the hypersimplified " Just say slavery " narrative of the American Civil War, or the pro-government narrative of the Whiskey Rebellion as "Federal law and order prevailed over frontier tax cheats." It is a surprisingly sentimental and romantic intellectual experience to hear the author describe bygone eras like the ...

Cod: A Biography of the Fish that Changed the World by Mark Kurlansky

History of the cod fishing industry across more than a millennium. The author begins with 10th century Viking and Basque explorers, and takes the reader on a roundabout journey right up to the modern era of global fishing moratoriums. In some ways this book is all over the place, its narrative at times only loosely connected to the cod industry, sometimes not at all. But it's okay: just enjoy the ride and let the author share what he knows. Which turns out to be a pretty interesting history on a subject you'd never expect would be so interesting. Each chapter has a postscript with one or two codfish recipes from a range of cultures and eras, some dating as far back as the 15th century. Once again it's more interesting than you'd expect: the preparation methods, the cuisine styles, even the recipe writing styles of these different eras. It adds an extra something to the book. [A quick  affiliate link to Amazon  for those readers who would like to support my work here: if...

Practical Speculation by Victor Niederhoffer and Laurel Kenner

Victor Niederhoffer: 1943-2026 Best suited for the intermediate-level investor or higher. Victor Niederhoffer is an eclectic, associative thinker: many of his ideas and insights emerge indirectly from what at first seem like off-topic tangents on literature, horse racing, sports or old films. Sometimes his writing requires a little extra patience, but it's always helpful to climb into his brain and poke around. You'll usually climb back out with a few new (and often highly unorthodox) ways to think about investing. I've always deeply respected Niederhoffer's candor about investing's various emotional and psychological challenges. Remember, he blew up twice : once in 1997 during the Asia crisis, and then a second time in 2007, four years after this book came out. Niederhoffer is entirely open about these blowups [1], and he is equally open about the regret, embarrassment and self-loathing that came with them. And yet each time, he returned to the game to try to lear...