Skip to main content

The Irony of American History by Reinhold Niebuhr

A densely written, difficult book, but very much worth reading. Predictive (almost prophetic you could say) of many of the struggles the USA faces now, nearly 70 years later. See, for example, the ugly ironies of modern culture wars, the invisible ironies of modern censorship, and saddest of all, the ironic struggle of working and middle classes under our technology overlords and government elites who, under the guise of "helping" us, increasingly control what we see, what we can say, and what we can do.

Niebuhr also points out in powerful ways the irony of "the pursuit of happiness" and how it places the individual in opposition to the collective, and how it leads ultimately to a vapid and vulgar culture.

The more powerful we have become as a nation, the less we are masters of our destiny. Niebuhr points out, again ironically, that we were a far greater master of our nation's destiny in the early decades of our history than we are now. When Niebuhr wrote this book in the early 1950s, we were totally unable to control the spread of international communism, we were unable to do anything about the USSR's complete hegemony over all of Eastern Europe, we stood helplessly by as China fell to Communism, and we were about to begin, with the conflict in Korea, the first of an endless list of "endless wars."

Today, you could argue we are more "powerful" than ever, yet far from controlling our destiny, we can hardly control ourselves at all. We bound from endless war to endless war across the Middle East, accomplishing nothing except adding strength and number to peoples who hate us (with good reason). And learning nothing: we further extended our wars into the domain of international trade, engaging in trade policies that ultimately gutted our own labor market, depressed our own workers' wages, and led to the export of most of our manufacturing base.

With all the power that we supposedly have, we remain nothing more than a "pitiful helpless giant" (to borrow the 1970s phrase from Richard Nixon), "living in an age of anarchy, both abroad and at home."

As individuals we are no less impotent. We allow our childish sociocultural tribalisms and our ill-informed ideological disputes to interfere with family, friendships and living a friendly, healthy life. And we always think we're right and the other guy is wrong! Another painful irony.

Finally, this book brought home to me, indirectly, the utter pointlessness of talking about politics. Keep in mind: Decades ago, Reinhold Niebuhr wrote a profound and deeply insightful book illustrating ironic hypocrisies throughout our political system. Today, no one reads this book (I only discovered it thanks to an obscure footnote in another obscure book that no one has ever read), and no one has even heard of Reinhold Niebuhr. Yet he's one of the 20th Century's most important philosopher-theologians! 

So why would we think there is any merit in offering our own unread, unremembered and ill-informed thoughts on politics in the postmodern era, which at their best take the form of virtue signalling and snarky putdowns on heavily-censored social media sites?

More Posts

For Good and Evil: The Impact of Taxes on the Course of Civilization by Charles Adams

Wide-ranging historical survey looking at major world civilizations through the lens of taxation and tax policy. It's a good read, a great review of world history, and it gets you to think about that history in a refreshingly unusual way. I've said elsewhere that one cannot understand history properly without some grounding in monetary history . Add tax history to the list! The author makes a robust argument that many if not most political instabilities and revolutions largely emerge out of resistance to punitive taxation. Likewise, this book will help deprogram readers away from the many schoolbook historical narratives we carry around, like the hypersimplified " Just say slavery " narrative of the American Civil War, or the pro-government narrative of the Whiskey Rebellion as "Federal law and order prevailed over frontier tax cheats." It is a surprisingly sentimental and romantic intellectual experience to hear the author describe bygone eras like the ...

Cod: A Biography of the Fish that Changed the World by Mark Kurlansky

History of the cod fishing industry across more than a millennium. The author begins with 10th century Viking and Basque explorers, and takes the reader on a roundabout journey right up to the modern era of global fishing moratoriums. In some ways this book is all over the place, its narrative at times only loosely connected to the cod industry, sometimes not at all. But it's okay: just enjoy the ride and let the author share what he knows. Which turns out to be a pretty interesting history on a subject you'd never expect would be so interesting. Each chapter has a postscript with one or two codfish recipes from a range of cultures and eras, some dating as far back as the 15th century. Once again it's more interesting than you'd expect: the preparation methods, the cuisine styles, even the recipe writing styles of these different eras. It adds an extra something to the book. [A quick  affiliate link to Amazon  for those readers who would like to support my work here: if...

Practical Speculation by Victor Niederhoffer and Laurel Kenner

Victor Niederhoffer: 1943-2026 Best suited for the intermediate-level investor or higher. Victor Niederhoffer is an eclectic, associative thinker: many of his ideas and insights emerge indirectly from what at first seem like off-topic tangents on literature, horse racing, sports or old films. Sometimes his writing requires a little extra patience, but it's always helpful to climb into his brain and poke around. You'll usually climb back out with a few new (and often highly unorthodox) ways to think about investing. I've always deeply respected Niederhoffer's candor about investing's various emotional and psychological challenges. Remember, he blew up twice : once in 1997 during the Asia crisis, and then a second time in 2007, four years after this book came out. Niederhoffer is entirely open about these blowups [1], and he is equally open about the regret, embarrassment and self-loathing that came with them. And yet each time, he returned to the game to try to lear...