Skip to main content

A Coffin for Dimitrios by Eric Ambler

"But what happened to Dimitrios? How did the story end?"

Colonel Haki snapped his fingers. "Ah! I was waiting for you to ask that. I knew you would ask it. And my answer is this: it didn't end!" 

As much as David Talbot's The Devil's Chessboard appalled me as it detailed the greed, arrogance and machiavellianism of my own country, I do thank that book for teaching me truths that I would have otherwise easily avoided, and I also thank it for indirectly introducing me to a few 20th-century spy novel authors that I would have never otherwise read.

Just as with Ambler's Journey Into Fear this book has an "average" protagonist, with yet another proto-modern twist: he is a spy-detective novel writer who finds himself in an actual spy-detective situation. Thus the book explores the difference between how a novelist looks at reality and how reality actually is--particularly from the perspective of real world investigators who do for real what he only writes about.  

And, again, this book teaches the reader more history: in this case it's a useful review of all the post-World War I chaos among Turkey, Greece, Armenia, Bulgaria and the Balkan republics. Remember, it was the major Versailles Treaty powers who divided up the world after the Great War and catastrophically interfered in all these countries: what followed was a tremendous amount of conflict and intrigue among Europe's smaller countries as everyone interfered in everyone's affairs. References in this novel to the 1923 coup d'état in Bulgaria and the murder of prime minister Aleksandar Stamboliyski was just one example of history I'd never heard of, and that sent me down a multi-hour Wikipedia rabbit hole to brush up.

I recommend A Coffin For Dimitrios more than Journey Into Fear. It carries more insights, and it's an interesting study of hyper-realism in the detective novel, as the main character, Latimer, discovers, with increasingly mortified humility, that reality and fiction are nothing alike, not even close:

     "The situation in which a person, imagining fondly that he is in charge of his own destiny, is, in fact, the sport of circumstances beyond his control, is always fascinating. It is the essential element in most good theater from the Oedipus of Sophocles to East Lynne. When, however, that person is oneself and one is examining the situation in retrospect, the fascination becomes a trifle morbid. Thus, when Latimer used afterwards to look back upon those two days in Smyrna, it was not so much his ignorance of the part he was playing but the bliss which accompanied the ignorance that so appalled him. He had gone into the business believing his eyes to be wide open, whereas, actually, they had been tightly shut. That, no doubt, could not have been helped. The galling part was that he had failed for so long to perceive the fact. Of course, he did himself less than justice; but his self-esteem had been punctured; he had been transferred without his knowledge from the role of sophisticated, impersonal weigher of facts to that of active participator in a melodrama.
     "Of the imminence of that humiliation, however, he had no inkling when, on the morning after his dinner with Muishkin, he sat down with a pencil and a notebook to arrange the material for his experiment in detection."

I can see now why so many later spy novelists (Ian Fleming, John Le Carré, among others) drew influence from Eric Ambler.

Notes: 
* There's good writing here and amusing characterizations of people, from an era where physiognomy was still in vogue and people believed it revealed information about a person's nature. One quick example: "The Greek was a dark, lean man of middle-age with intelligent rather bulbous eyes and a way of bringing his lips together at the end of a sentence as though amazed at his own lack of discretion."

* Another example of good--and extraordinarily insightful--writing: "In a dying civilization, political prestige is the reward not of the shrewdest diagnostician but of the man with the best bedside manner. It is the decoration conferred on mediocrity by ignorance." A quote to remember for this era as American civilization declines.

* Re: Talbot's The Devil's Chessboard again: ironically, the early architects of the CIA drew aspects of their "business model" and modes of operation from the prior era's spy novels, Eric Ambler and John Buchan among others. Yet another example of how life imitates art.

* Finally note this quote from Goethe, from Pandora: "Ach! warum, ihr Götter, ist unendlich, alles, alles, endlich unser Glück nur?" [Oh why, ye Gods, is everything infinite, everything, except our happiness?] One to file away. 

More Posts

Why We Sleep by Matthew Walker

Tedious, weak, and worst of all  "riddled" with errors  and oversights. Do not read. I recommend instead  Dreaming: A Very Short Introduction  by J. Allan Hobson  for information about the REM/dreaming stage of sleep, as well as  Restful Sleep  by Deepak Chopra  for readers interested in practical help for improving sleep quality. Unlike Why We Sleep , both of these books are short, direct, readable and clear. Sadly, I also have to spend a brief few sentences  on Alexey Guzey's devastating criticisms of this book . Alexey's entire post is very much worth reading, but if you want to see just one glaring example of atrocious academic ethics, you can start with a chart Matthew Walker uses in Chapter 6 to prove a linear relationship between sleep loss and sports injury-- except that he cuts off the part of the chart that disproves his argument . This is childish middle school stuff, way beneath the line of a Berkeley and Harvard professor, a...

By All Means Available: Memoirs of a Life in Intelligence, Special Operations, and Strategy by Michael G. Vickers

The least deceptive way to read this endless, muddled and minutia-laden memoir would be to view it as a very long piece of propaganda: a type of limited hangout of all of the covert (and overt) things the United States does globally in its attempts to project power. It can also be read as an attempt at an extended--and I mean extended --defense of the CIA and all of its meddlings all over the world. This is if you actually read the book. Don't. Piled up with words but saying little of substance, this is the most obfuscatory memoir I've ever read. The author's voice fundamentally irritates: he has a compulsive need to share staggering amounts of unnecessary detail, he comes across as a relentless credit hog, and he repeatedly attempts to place himself right in the middle of the action--even when it's clear he wasn't. Perhaps least ethical of all, he has a habit of framing his actions and decisions so they appear more correct and predictive in retrospect than they ac...

The Dhandho Investor by Mohnish Pabrai

Worth reading, and rereading, and re-rereading. An elegant book that teaches fundamental principles of value investing, and much more. The Dhandho Investor  also has the highly unusual quality of being useful at a wide range of reader sophistication levels: you can gain tremendously from this book as a beginner or as a deeply experienced investor. I'll single out Chapters 5 and 6 for particular mention: Chapter 5 describes author Mohnish Pabrai's investing framework, with nine interlocking and synchronistic rules. Chapter 6 describes in very simple language all of the gigantic structural advantages of investing in the stock market, as it offers low frictional costs, a tremendous selection of possible businesses, and, most importantly, periodic incredible opportunities. These two chapters explain why you will take a pass on almost all investments--but then, once in a while, make large bets on specific situations that meet your requirements. [A quick  affiliate link to Amazon ...